In several past Graphs About Songs, I’ve showcased songs from previous decades that appear in the Spotify 200 chart alongside today’s biggest hits. I’ve asserted that young people love these songs, since the younger you are, the more time you spend with Spotify.
A fair question, however, is how do you know that the same listeners streaming these old songs are primarily fans of today’s hits?
Today, we return to LiveLine with Mason Kelter, the nationally syndicated request-driven evening show airing on over 90 radio stations in the U.S. Specifically, we’re examining the show’s Top 20 requests that LiveLine publishes on Instagram and in the “Mason’s Observations” column on RadioInsight and in Sean Ross’ “Ross on Radio” newsletter. I’ve gathered those requests from September 12th, 2025 through October 24th, 2026.
Alongside the latest hits from Taylor Swift, Olivia Rodrigo, and sombr are a variety of older songs. The people requesting these songs are specifically listening to a show focused on today’s hits on a radio station exclusively playing hit music. In other words, these listeners are fans of today’s biggest hits. And yet, they sometimes request songs that are decades old.
What are these songs and why are hit music fans requesting them?
The old songs young fans request most… and why
Traditional Media
The biopic Michael launched several Jackson classics back into the popular Zeitgeist. Long after the film left the theater, fans still request Michael’s music. “Thriller” (1983) peaks approaching Halloween, but fans have rediscovered that it’s not a Halloween song. “Billie Jean“ (1983) remained in the Liveline Top 20 every single week from early May to late September, peaking at #6. “Beat It“ was a top request for six weeks, peaking at #7. The most surprising request is Michael Jackson’s “Chicago” (2014), a track recorded in 1999 but released posthumously on the album XSCAPE
The TV finale for Stranger Things also generated requests for Prince’s “Purple Rain” (1984), although the song was only among the Top 20 most-requested for two weeks.
Death of an Icon
Most LiveLine listeners weren’t even alive when Dolly Parton had her last solo #1 Country hit in 1989. And yet, as soon as she left us, listeners who would normally call in for Tate McRae wanted to hear Dolly Parton’s “9 to 5” (1980) and “Jolene” (1973) for several weeks.
Events
Justin Bieber, Nicki Minaj’s “Beauty And A Beat” (2012) remained a Top 20 request for 17 non-consecutive weeks, thanks to Bieber’s Coachella comeback.
UK’s unofficial theme song of the FIFA World Cup made “Wonderwall” (1995) a Top 20 request for a week.
Social Media
It was that viral skateboarding video that brought back Fleetwood Mac’s “Dreams” (1977). The song has never gone away. A TikTok trend recently brought back Katy Perry’s “The One That Got Away” (2011) Three different songs from about ten years ago are among the top requests thanks to the #BringBack2016 trend, namely Drake, Wizkid, Kylad’s “One Dance” (2016), The Weeknd, Daft Punk’s “Starboy” (2016), and Fetty Wap’s “Trap Queen” (2015).
Seasonal
There’s something about fall that makes people want to hear about it in song. Noah Kahan “Stick Season” (2022) and The Neighbourhood “Sweater Weather” (2012) both join the Top 20 requests when the leaves start changing.
Evergreens
Then there are those songs that don’t need an occasion: They include the Goo Goo Dolls’ “Iris” (1998), Katy Perry & Snoop Dog’s “California Gurls” (2010), and of course The Killers’ “Mr. Brightside” (2004).
Here are the Top 16 older songs requested on Liveline from September 25th, 2025 through October 25th, 2026, based on how many weeks each song was among the Top 20 requests:
These Classics are the exceptions
It’s important to note that there is no wholesale acceptance of older songs by younger listeners. Younger fans have rediscovered this handful of specific songs for specific reasons. As Mason himself noted in a recent Mason’s Observations:
“it is the fresh discovery by young people of a few specific gold superhits which through socials, Tik Tok and YouTube they have discovered and reacted to en masse. There will certainly be no sudden boost in 18-24 numbers on the Classic Hits stations”
While the total number of older songs requested on Liveline may well be higher, the vast majority (90%) of the 20 most-requested songs in a typical week are for current hits.
However, Mason has also been quick to advocate that older songs that are enjoying current cultural relevance should have a place on hit music radio:
“They’re listening to your station that plays Sabrina Carpenter, Justin Bieber, Taylor Swift, and Bruno Mars. They know what Top 40 is. Sometimes what’s relevant to them is Dolly or Michael Jackson. Sometimes it’s a song they heard in a movie, discovered on TikTok or had somebody play for them in the car. To them, that’s a hit. Right now.”
What do you think? Is the station that promises you “Today’s Hit Music” violating that promise when they play a decades-old song? Or, should a Pop music station focus on whatever songs are popular and culturally relevant with their listeners right now, regardless of the song’s release date? I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments below.
Data Source for this article:
Liveline Top 20 requests, retrieved from https://www.instagram.com/livelineradio/







